Baby Stuff Lab compares top-rated Colgate Baby Crib Mattresses by analyzing reviews and customer feedback. You can easily choose the right one from our Editor Pick List.
Top Rated Colgate Baby Crib Mattresses
No. 1 
Colgate Mattress EcoClassica III Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress - Dual-Firmness Infant and Toddler Mattress with Thick, Sustainable Foam and Certified...
- THIS FOAM CRIB MATTRESS is packed with 6” of thick foam and has an infant side that is engineered to provide the proper firmness needed for growth and development, while the less-firm side provides...
- ECO-FRIENDLIER FOAM in this infant and toddler bed mattress is made using sustainable plant oils
- WRAPPED IN ORGANIC COTTON COVER with food grade waterproof backing, featuring a durable topside waterproofing that ensures quick and easy cleanups for those middle-of-the-night diaper accidents
- SQUARE CORNERS and inverted seam for a snug fit in all standard-size American cribs and toddler beds
- HYPOALLERGENIC & PHTHALATE FREE
Save $33.00No. 2 
Colgate Mattress Classica III Crib Mattress - Lightweight Dual-Firmness Infant and Toddler Mattress with Thick, Foam and Triple-Layered Tear-Resistant...
- BREATHABLE CRIB MATTRESS with multiple side vents for increased airflow
- THIS FOAM CRIB MATTRESS has 5.5” of hypoallergenic CertiPUR-US certified foam and is engineered to provide the proper firmness needed for growth and development
- WRAPPED SNUGLY INSIDE A TRIPLE-LAYERED COVER that is reinforced, waterproof, and tear-resistant that is easy to clean for mom and dad
- SQUARE CORNERS for a snug fit in all standard-size American cribs and toddler beds
- HYPOALLERGENIC & PHTHALATE FREE
No. 3 
Colgate Mattress CuddleSnooze Foam Grand Crib Mattress - Breathable Dual-Firmness Infant and Toddler Mattress Featuring Plush Knitted Cover with...
- BREATHABLE INFANT AND TODDLER MATTRESS designed to lull baby into a cozy, sound, and restful sleep throughout the infant and toddler years
- THE INFANT SIDE is a firm foam crib mattress of high-density EcoFoam that provides the proper firmness needed for growth and development
- THE TODDLER SIDE features a less-firm EcoFoam that provides the comfort toddlers prefer, for an exceptionally soft toddler bed mattress
- KEEPING SAFETY FIRST, the CuddleSnooze Foam Grand is handcrafted with an anti-flammability barrier made with chemical-free cloth
- BREATHABLE HONEYCOMB MESH SPACER provides optimal airflow for temperature regulation and maximum sleeping comfort
No. 4 
Colgate Mattress 2-N-1 - Breathable Dual-Firmness Crib Mattress Designed for Infants & Toddlers Featuring Innerspring Unit and Two Cushioning Layers...
- BREATHABLE CRIB MATTRESS is hypoallergenic and phthalate free with multiple side vents for increased air flow and freshness, built with strong cloth binding seams for durability
- FITS ALL STANDARD SIZE American cribs and toddler beds
- WATERPROOF COVER is triple-layered and tear-resistant
- DUAL-FIRMNESS designed for the firmness infants need for proper development and the toddler side is softer for the comfort preferred in a toddler mattress
- HIGH QUALITY INNERSPRING UNIT is made of 135 coils of thick 13.5-guage tempered steel and 9.0-guage border rods for sturdy edge support and firmness
No. 5 
Colgate Mattress Ultra II - Orthopedic-Style Crib Mattress Featuring Multiple Side Vents for Breathability and Freshness with Springs and Waterproof...
- BREATHABLE CRIB MATTRESS includes multiple side vents to ensure mattress freshness and promotes a healthy sleep environment
- HIGH QUALITY SPRING UNIT includes 150 coils of thick 13.5-gauge steel coils, with 9.0-gauge steel border rods for sturdy edge support
- WATERPROOF COVER is triple-layered and tear resistant to make cleaning and changing sheets on the baby mattress easy
- HYPOALLERGENIC & PHTHALATE FREE and fits all standard size American cribs and toddler beds
- TWO LAYERS OF COTTON BATTING for extra comfort and support
No. 6 
Colgate Mattress Natural I - Metal and Plastic-Free Crib Mattress Featuring Square Cornered Inverted-Seam Design with Certified Organic Cotton Cloth...
- HEALTHIEST BABY MATTRESS FINALIST in 2016 Cribsie Awards
- ALL-NATURAL MATERIALS includes no metal or plastic
- SQUARE CORNERS for a snug fit in all standard-size American cribs and toddler beds
- CERTIFIED ORGANIC COTTON COVER is tear-resistant and hypoallergenic, perfect for a toddler bed mattress
- NATURAL COMPONENTS include coir fiber from coconut shell husks and renewable cotton batting cushioning for a soft, safe toddler mattress
No. 7 
Colgate Mattress Eco Spring 2-N-1 - Dual-Firmness Crib Mattress Featuring Eco-Friendlier Foam and Spring Unit with Ultra-Soft Certified Organic Cotton...
- THE INFANT SIDE features the firmness infants need in a baby mattress for development and safety
- THE TODDLER SIDE is engineered to provide the comfort preferred in a toddler mattress
- HIGH QUALITY INNERSPRING UNIT is made of 190 extra-thick 14-gauge steel coils with 6.0-gauge steel border rods for sturdy edge support
- ULTRA-SOFT, TEAR-RESISTANT COVER is made with certified organic cotton
- COIR FIBER INSULATOR PAD is made from renewable coconut shell husks
No. 8 
Stokke Sleepi Mattress with Organic Cover by Colgate, White - Foam Crib Mattress with Infant Support & Safety Features - Compatible Sleepi Crib/Bed
- COMFORT & SUPPORT - The foam and extra-firm polyethylene layer in the Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress with Organic Cotton Cover by Colgate provide support & pressure relief so your baby can rest...
- INNOVATIVE MATERIAL - The mattress features an innovative material called NaturesWeave, a matrix of fibers that enhance the open air construction of the mattress and dissipates heat from your child as...
- MADE IN THE USA - Stokke Sleepi Mattress with Organic Cover is designed by Stokke and handcrafted in the USA by Colgate. Plus, it’s Greenguard Gold Certified.
- DESIGN WITH A PURPOSE - Stokke entered the children's furniture & accessories sector in 1972, and since then, all our products have been designed to challenge the ordinary, foster healthy development,...
No. 9 
Colgate Mattress zenBaby 2-Stage Crib Mattress - Features 5-Inch Thick Dual-Zone Hypoallergenic Ecofoam with KulKote Technology on Infant Side for...
- 5-INCH THICK baby mattress is lightweight and eco-friendly with extra-firm and medium-firm dualzone certified safe ecofoam
- INFANT SIDE features eco-foam with Kulkote technology for optimal temperature regulation and comfort
- TODDLER SIDE features medium-firm ecofoam for the comfort preferred for a toddler bed mattress
- DIMENSIONS: 52” X 27.5” X 6”
- ULTRA-SOFT, WATERPROOF RAYON COVER with built-in extra loft for comfort with food-grade backing
No. 10 
Colgate Mattress Classica I - Lightweight Breathable Crib Mattress with Multiple Side Eyelet Vents, Square-Cornered Design, and Waterproof,...
- CHOSEN #1 of all baby crib mattresses by the nation’s leading consumer products magazine
- RECOMMENDED by leading Baby Bargains publications for 15 years
- BREATHABLE CRIB MATTRESS with multiple side vents for increased airflow to keep your toddler mattress fresh
- WATERPROOF COVER is tear-resistant and triple-layered
- SQUARE CORNERS for a snug fit and cleans easily with damp cloth and mild soap
Last update on 2023-05-31
